If it feels harder to capture the attention of prospective members these days, you’re not imagining it. Between inbox overload, competing demands, and shrinking attention spans, your prospects are tuning out generic messages faster than ever.

The part we don’t talk about enough, though? Most associations still rely almost entirely on email to drive new-member growth… even though 65% of recruitment emails never get opened. 

That means you’re working twice as hard just to get half as far.

The good news is, we have good news. And that is - associations are finding success again by shifting one thing: starting real conversations earlier, in more places, and with more intention.

Let’s dive a bit deeper, shall we? 

The Problem: Acquisition Isn’t Broken… It’s Just More Complicated

Associations aren’t struggling because their value has disappeared. They’re struggling because the way people make decisions has changed. Ten years ago, you could send one recruitment email and see a decent response. Today, that same email gets buried under dozens of notifications, promotional offers, and competing priorities. Prospects make decisions in micro-moments now, i.e. quick glances, not long sales pitches.

In other words, prospective members are overwhelmed. And overwhelmed people are much harder to convert.

The Shift: Conversations, Not Campaigns

What we’re seeing work right now isn’t more messaging. It’s more dialogue. Instead of broadcasting information, the most successful associations are:

• Asking simple questions (at the moment people are actually looking for something)
• Capturing intent instead of just clicks
• Following up in real time with resources that feel personal
• Guiding prospects forward instead of pushing them to “Join Now” before they’re ready
• Using multiple channels that work together instead of operating in silos
  
  

This is the heart of PropFuel’s Ask → Capture → Act framework:

Ask a question → Capture the insight → Act with relevance.

And we’ve got more good news…you don’t need a 20-person marketing team for this, you just need a clear path and the willingness to rethink where the journey begins.

What’s Working Now: Start on the Website

The biggest change we’ve seen over the last year is associations finally treating their website as the beginning of the acquisition journey, not the end of it.

Your website already attracts prospects every day. They come with curiosity. With intent. With questions you can’t see. But for most associations, the interaction ends there because there’s no way to engage.

We’re here to tell you it’s really truly possible to turn that static traffic into a moment of conversation, which really changes everything. 

If you don’t believe us, let me break it down for you by showing some real-world examples. 

Case Study #1: Academy of Model Aeronautics (AMA)

Turning a single website pop-up into 5,000+ leads and 1,400 new members

AMA had great content, strong programs, and steady traffic, but anonymous visitors weren’t converting. They were clicking around, getting overwhelmed, and leaving without ever telling AMA who they were or what they needed.

So, AMA added one simple question to their site: “What brings you to our site today?”

Visitors chose from clear options (Become a Member, Find a Club, Learn to Fly), then provided their name and email so AMA could send the right resource.

That one question did three things:

1. Captured intent before the prospect left
2. Captured contact information so AMA could follow up
3. Delivered immediate value by directing them to the exact page they needed
   
   

And because AMA used PropFuel, every choice triggered an automated, personalized next step:

• Redirect to the right page
• A follow-up email based on their intent
• Enrollment in a relevant nurture series
• Staff alerts for prospects who needed human support

The results are staggering:

• 5,000+ new contacts in weeks
• 1,400 new member conversions
• $114,000+ in membership revenue

This happened not because AMA started the acquisition journey by ASKING. 

Case Study #2: Emergency Nurses Association (ENA)

Leading with empathy and generating 9,739 responses + 395 new leads

ENA tackled a very different challenge: how do you reach nurses dealing with workplace violence, one of the most urgent issues in the field? And they took a very different approach. They were looking to provide a relevant resource to prospects to show value up front. 

So, instead of starting with a sales pitch, ENA asked a deeply relevant question right on their homepage: “Have you ever experienced workplace violence in the emergency department?”

Visitors selected Yes, No, or Not Sure. From there, ENA immediately offered a high-value resource: a comprehensive Workplace Violence Toolkit.

To access it, visitors exchanged their name and email, which built a lead list of highly relevant prospects who genuinely needed support.

Then ENA followed up with:

• A personalized email
• A resource landing page
• A nurture sequence offering additional value before ever asking for a membership

The outcomes:

• 9,739 responses
• 395 new leads
• 19 new members in the first weeks (before the full campaign even completed)

ENA’s approach? Let’s show value first by connecting with prospects in a way they know ENA understands them and is here to support them. 

The Common Thread: One Question Can Start an Entire Journey

Though AMA and ENA approached acquisition differently, their success rests on the same foundation:

• They started with one meaningful question, not a generic pitch.
• They met visitors where they already were: the website. And carried on the conversation from there. 
• They delivered value immediately, before asking for anything back.
• They used automation to follow up based on behavior, not assumptions.
• They treated acquisition as a conversation, not a one-time campaign.

This is conversational engagement in action. When you shift from “Here’s everything we want you to know” to “What are you looking for, and how can we help?”, prospects convert faster and with more trust.

How Associations Can Apply This Today

If you want to build smarter acquisition campaigns, here’s where to start:

1. Look at where prospects already show up.

Your website. Your webinars. Your events. Your education pages. Anywhere curiosity exists is a chance to start a conversation.

2. Ask one simple, relevant question.

Keep it short and keep it human: 

“What brings you to our site today?”

“What’s your top priority this year?”

“What’s the biggest challenge you’re navigating right now?”

3. Offer immediate value.

A resource. A link. A checklist. A guide. Something…anything…that answers the prospect’s need before asking them to join.

4. Collect contact information with purpose.

People don’t mind sharing their email when they genuinely get something helpful, so make the value worth the exchange. 

5. Follow up with intention.

Use automation to send:

• A personalized email
• A relevant resource
• A path forward that matches what they chose

Don’t guess…respond to what they actually told you.

6. Build a short nurture sequence.

Three to five touches is often enough when each message aligns with their goals.

7. Use multiple channels that work together.

Email + website + SMS + social = a connected journey, not isolated touchpoints.

The Big Takeaway: Personalization Beats Promotion Every Time

Acquisition is about showing up in the right moments with the right conversation.

When you start with a question, you learn what matters. When you act on what you learn, you build trust. And when you build trust, new members follow.

If you’re ready to rethink your approach and start turning anonymous visitors into engaged future members, PropFuel is here to help.

Build a Smarter Member Acquisition Journey

Want to see how PropFuel can help you capture intent, personalize outreach, and increase conversions across your website, email, and SMS?

Book a demo with our team and see conversational engagement in action.

‍